Many cats are creatures of habit. I purposely steer away from using the term “finicky” because it implies cats are just that way forever and cannot be changed—like they were born with some sort of “finicky” gene. Habits can be changed, and a creature of habit has a chance of changing or learning a new, healthier habit. It may take a little work, but pets can be weaned away from dangerously addictive commercial foods by using bribes—treats offered to entice a pet to eat healthier. My experience has been that when cat owners switch to feeding healthier food, about half of the cats take to the new food immediately. The other half often look at the food, then caterwaul around the kitchen demanding their old food or simply walk away uninterested. Particularly reticent and expressive cats may try to bury the food. These bribes are fine for all cats, but they’re specifically designed for the unwilling half.
Mother’s Little Helpers: Treats as Bribes - If your pet is reluctant to make the switch to its new diet, sometimes a little something extra will coax them to the food bowl. Think of these bribes as tasty condiments to add some zing to their meal! The functional foods listed below can entice your pet, but most of them are also healthful and serve as supplements, providing extra vitamins, proteins, or other nutrients. A heartier cat will love the meats, eggs, and cheeses, while a cat under the weather will greatly appreciate the eggs, olive oil, or yogurt.
Meat slivers (chicken, turkey, beef, lamb, or fish; avoid ham, pork, and tuna products)
A few small pieces of cooked organic liver
A few drops of natural tamari
A few shakes of natural Parmesan cheese
A dollop of tomato sauce
A teaspoon of organic plain yogurt
A spoonful of oil from a jar of olives
A finely chopped olive
A dollop of cottage cheese
A dollop of meat-based baby food
Raw or soft-boiled egg
Try mixing a bit of any of the above bribe foods into the new food or sprinkling it on top. Sometimes an irresistible condiment is all it takes to get a reluctant pet revved up and excited about the new fare. If there’s something you know your cat is wild about, get creative and use just a little bit to get it going. Dogs don’t usually need any coaxing to try the new meals, but any of the bribe foods can be used for dogs, as well.